The year 2026 started with a strange reading habit. One book in January—Makanya, Mikir! by @Abigail and @Cania. But that was enough. Enough to get me curious. February brought two books. March? A book every week or two. It’s May now and the pattern hasn’t let up.

Back Then

Back when a friend talked about their relationship about how they were sad, hurt, always the one losing out.

I had one answer,

JUST BREAK UP.

“What’s the point of staying together if you always lose, always end up sad?”

I said it without blinking, as if CBA were the universal language. If they stayed anyway, I called them stupid.

I knew emotions were a factor. But emotions felt like noise sitting on top of the logic that was “really” there.

That “noise” had a name the whole time. Economics likes to model decisions as if emotion doesn’t exist, just cost-benefit.

Damasio’s somatic marker hypothesis says the opposite:

in messy, uncertain situations, the body’s emotional signals are what help the brain narrow the options down. They aren’t interference. Take them away and every choice turns into a slow, exhausting cost-benefit analysis.42

Then I read Prinsipil Ekonomi by @Ferry Irwandi. It taught me the basics, how to understand economic language simply and accurately. But one point stuck: humans are never purely rational. Emotion is always in the room. That’s what makes people varied, unpredictable, impossible to flatten into simple logic.

Turns out I wasn’t quoting something fringe. A proper review of Damasio’s hypothesis calls it “elegant” and says outright that emotion does affect decisions, then asks for more causal evidence before calling it settled.4 So “humans are never purely rational“ was already old news in psychology. The argument is about how much, not whether.

I knew this in theory. But knowing ≠ believing.

Then A Gentle Reminder by @Bianca Sparacino. The book is about the self and intimacy, but the pages I kept flipping back to were about how good it feels when someone understands what you’re feeling.

Connection isn’t measured by time, but by how deeply it helps you understand yourself. You can love someone for years and lose yourself in the process. Just as easily, you can meet someone for a week and see your whole soul in them.

Understood, not reasoned at.

And it turns out “feeling understood” isn’t just a nice feeling. It has numbers behind it. A 2023 review says

we lean on the feeling of being understood, even when it’s not perfectly accurate, to decide whether we like someone and whether we stay.6

A two-week diary study found people reported higher life satisfaction and fewer aches and pains on the days they felt understood.7

Another one, four experiments and 945 people, found it reshapes the self:

the relationship moves closer to the center of who you are. Not because you were proven right. Because the world suddenly makes more sense.1

Which is exactly what I was doing when I swapped “correctionbreak up or not?” for “what do you see in them?”. I’d switched modes, evaluator to listener. Apparently it does more than feel nice.

Later On

There’s no single moment when I noticed I’d changed. But now, when a friend talks about the same thing a relationship that makes them sad I don’t tell them to break up right away. I ask,

“Why do you still want to hold on?”

“What is it you see in them?”

I ask them to figure themselves out first.

“Try looking at it not from the economic angle, even though that’s the one that jumps out first. Look at the mental side and the happiness. Is it worth what you’re holding onto?”

And when they stayed anyway, “correctionstupid“ was the label I kept handing out. Now I get it:

they’re vulnerable to sweet talk and beautiful promises, because they want to believe.

Because they need to believe. And that’s fair. Very fair, especially when falling in love.

Psychology has a word for it: traumatic bonding. The first real test, 75 women who’d just walked out of abusive relationships, found that the hot and cold pattern and the power gap explained 55% of how attached they still felt six months later.5

A 2023 study, 354 people still in it, adds childhood neglect and insecure attachment to the picture, even after age, gender and romantic love are controlled for.9

But it wasn’t a smooth transformation. There are moments when my logic mode flares up, when the first thing I think is, this makes no sense. And I have to pause before I answer, hear the feeling out before logic takes the wheel. I keep having to remind myself:

There’s context I can’t see. There’s a valid reason.

I didn’t know it then, but that line is basically Geertz’s thick description:

don’t stop at “stupid” or “marriage”. Spell out what the thing means to the person living it.8

What I’d been doing was the exact opposite, what psychologists call fundamental attribution error: Blame the person, skip the situation. Turns out even that reflex isn’t universal. Easterners are more likely to hold both sides of a conflict in view; Westerners dig in.8 So maybe the change in me isn’t that I got nicer. It’s that I got more accurate. “Nicer” was a side effect.

One thing I still check, though: understanding isn’t the same as excusing. That 2023 study also found traumatic bonding sits right next to Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder symptoms.9 Natural isn’t the same as healthy. And “why do you stay?” still isn’t the question I should be asking. “What do you need right now?” is.

Right Now

I feel different now. Calmer. Calm enough not to judge, even though my logic is still shouting in the background.

When this doesn’t hold

  • Empathy has blind spots. Decety’s review points out that empathy evolved for kin and your own crowd. One visible person pulls at us harder than a crowd we can’t picture, and that can run straight into fairness.3 So “understand first, logic later” isn’t a rule I’d defend everywhere. Sometimes the principle has to go first.
  • Feelings aren’t automatic truth. The critique of somatic marker says the evidence is still thinner than the story sounds.4 I’m careful not to trade one rigid thing, “CBA is everything”, for another: “the feeling is always right”.
  • Feeling understood isn’t the whole story. In those four studies, understanding held up even when care and acceptance were low.1 A relationship can feel deeply “seen” and still not be good for you. Identity isn’t a scorecard.
  • Not everything is context. Cultural materialists think thick description can get in the way of explanation, because the real causes often aren’t visible even to the person living them.8